National Technical Reports Library

The National Technical Information Service acquires, indexes, abstracts, and archives the largest collection of U.S. government-sponsored technical reports in existence. The NTRL offers online, free and open access to these authenticated government technical reports. Technical reports and documents in its repository may be available online for free either from the issuing federal agency, the U.S. Government Publishing Office’s Federal Digital System website, or through search engines.

Details

Can Fuzzy Logic Bring Complex Problems into Focus. Modeling Imprecise Factors in Environmental Policy.

DE2004834236

Publication Date	2004
Page Count	22
Abstract	In modeling complex environmental problems, we often fail to make precise statements about inputs and outcome. In this case the fuzzy logic method native to the human mind provides a useful way to get at these problems. Fuzzy logic represents a significant change in both the approach to and outcome of environmental evaluations. Risk assessment is currently based on the implicit premise that probability theory provides the necessary and sufficient tools for dealing with uncertainty and variability. The key advantage of fuzzy methods is the way they reflect the human mind in its remarkable ability to store and process information which is consistently imprecise, uncertain, and resistant to classification. Our case study illustrates the ability of fuzzy logic to integrate statistical measurements with imprecise health goals. But we submit that fuzzy logic and probability theory are complementary and not competitive. In the world of soft computing, fuzzy logic has been widely used and has often been the 'smart' behind smart machines. But it will require more effort and case studies to establish its niche in risk assessment or other types of impact assessment. Although we often hear complaints about 'bright lines,' could we adapt to a system that relaxes these lines to fuzzy gradations. Would decision makers and the public accept expressions of water or air quality goals in linguistic terms with computed degrees of certainty. Resistance is likely. In many regions, such as the US and European Union, it is likely that both decision makers and members of the public are more comfortable with our current system in which government agencies avoid confronting uncertainties by setting guidelines that are crisp and often fail to communicate uncertainty. But some day perhaps a more comprehensive approach that includes exposure surveys, toxicological data, epidemiological studies coupled with fuzzy modeling will go a long way in resolving some of the conflict, divisiveness, and controversy in the current regulatory paradigm.
Keywords	Fuzzy logic Environmental policy Risk assessment Case studies Probability
Source Agency	Technical Information Center Oak Ridge Tennessee
Corporate Authors	California Univ., Berkeley.; Department of Energy, Washington, DC.; National Environmental Engineering Research Inst., Nagpur (India).
Supplemental Notes	Prepared in cooperation with National Environmental Engineering Research Inst., Nagpur (India). Sponsored by Department of Energy, Washington, DC.
Document Type	Technical Report
NTIS Issue Number	200515

Can Fuzzy Logic Bring Complex Problems into Focus. Modeling Imprecise Factors in Environmental Policy.

Can Fuzzy Logic Bring Complex Problems into Focus. Modeling Imprecise Factors in Environmental Policy.
DE2004834236

Publication Date	2004
Page Count	22
Abstract	In modeling complex environmental problems, we often fail to make precise statements about inputs and outcome. In this case the fuzzy logic method native to the human mind provides a useful way to get at these problems. Fuzzy logic represents a significant change in both the approach to and outcome of environmental evaluations. Risk assessment is currently based on the implicit premise that probability theory provides the necessary and sufficient tools for dealing with uncertainty and variability. The key advantage of fuzzy methods is the way they reflect the human mind in its remarkable ability to store and process information which is consistently imprecise, uncertain, and resistant to classification. Our case study illustrates the ability of fuzzy logic to integrate statistical measurements with imprecise health goals. But we submit that fuzzy logic and probability theory are complementary and not competitive. In the world of soft computing, fuzzy logic has been widely used and has often been the 'smart' behind smart machines. But it will require more effort and case studies to establish its niche in risk assessment or other types of impact assessment. Although we often hear complaints about 'bright lines,' could we adapt to a system that relaxes these lines to fuzzy gradations. Would decision makers and the public accept expressions of water or air quality goals in linguistic terms with computed degrees of certainty. Resistance is likely. In many regions, such as the US and European Union, it is likely that both decision makers and members of the public are more comfortable with our current system in which government agencies avoid confronting uncertainties by setting guidelines that are crisp and often fail to communicate uncertainty. But some day perhaps a more comprehensive approach that includes exposure surveys, toxicological data, epidemiological studies coupled with fuzzy modeling will go a long way in resolving some of the conflict, divisiveness, and controversy in the current regulatory paradigm.
Keywords	Fuzzy logic Environmental policy Risk assessment Case studies Probability
Source Agency	Technical Information Center Oak Ridge Tennessee
Corporate Authors	California Univ., Berkeley.; Department of Energy, Washington, DC.; National Environmental Engineering Research Inst., Nagpur (India).
Supplemental Notes	Prepared in cooperation with National Environmental Engineering Research Inst., Nagpur (India). Sponsored by Department of Energy, Washington, DC.
Document Type	Technical Report
NTIS Issue Number	200515